Journeys Are My Diary

Life, Adventures, Entertainment and more - A little bit of everything blog!

Page to Screen – James and the Giant Peach

by Leave a Comment

james-the-giant-peach

I have a really old copy of James and the Giant Peach, which I think maybe belonged to my mum once upon a time. However it’s also the copy I’ve had since childhood and read then too. While I’ve always remembered the rough plot of James and the Giant Peach, it wasn’t until recently that I re-read it, with Lily as a bedtime story. I forgot how old-fashioned the writing style is and even how Roald Dahl’s writing was. That’s not to say it was unenjoyable because it wasn’t, but I did wonder if Lily would both follow the style and enjoy it herself.

I needn’t have worried though, as she loved it. The beginning was sad, with James’ parents dying and him moving in with his Aunts. The agony drawn out over a few chapters while we discover how miserable they made him and how sorry we felt for him. Then the magic, the growing peach and the journey. It’s a lovely simple story but wonderful nonetheless and a great bedtime story as the chapters are really short.

Over Christmas, I spotted that the movie of James and the Giant Peach was on TV and so I set it to record. Of course Christmas can be crazy busy and we never got around to watching it. However last night we finally sat down together and since I had fabric to cut and needed the lounge floor, I put on the movie. I hadn’t realised it was by Disney but that gave me hope, though I spotted Tim Burton’s name on the credits and did wonder if that would make it a little weird.

images

The beginning of the movie, was a little over exaggerated. It reminded me somewhat of scenes from Big Fish, but since that’s one of my favourite movies, it wasn’t necessarily off-putting. The rest of the beginning was fairly standard and as expected, the Aunts being fairly horrible and James being as expected. The peach grew, the adventure began and really that was where the movie lost it for me.

James

First the movie style change, which was okay and completely understandable to be honest. However then the storyline changed and that wasn’t okay. For the most part, the journey was similar to the book and changed only to make it more interesting I guess (though I wasn’t keen). However the journey specifically to New York wasn’t quite accurate, even though that is where the peach ended up. The drama with his Aunts arriving in New York (they were supposed to be dead) was ridiculous and the typical US movie “speech” that was given by James was pretty over the top too. All in all, when the movie ended, I felt disappointed. Lily even said “well that was a let down”.

I know movies get changed when they go from page to screen but I wasn’t keen on these changes. I really enjoy Roald Dahl’s writing and while many of his books do seem a little outdated these days, they are still good classics. Some movie adaptations have worked, while others haven’t. But I didn’t really enjoy this one. I think I’ll stick to Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and Matilda from now on, though we have Fantastic Mr Fox on the sky box to watch at some point too.

Page to Screen – Before I Go To Sleep

by Leave a Comment

bigts

A few years ago I read a book called “Before I Go to Sleep” by S. J. Watson. I’d treated myself to a Kindle and I got this book really cheap, so it was one of the first I read on my kindle. I loved it so much that I recommended it to everyone, but sadly having it on kindle meant I wasn’t able to lend it to anyone! Anyway over the years my mum has read it and my best friend is currently reading it – my mum loved it but sadly I don’t think Nat has really give it a chance yet (being in the middle of 4 books at a time!).

Anyway, when it was announced that 2014 would see a movie adaptation of this book, I was pretty excited. I’m not a huge Nicole Kidman fan though so when she was cast as the lead, I couldn’t really see it. Needless to say I didn’t manage to get to the cinema to see the movie and actually even when it came out on dvd I was waiting for Nat to watch it with me. However after waiting indefinitely I decided to just watch it tonight – I have it on Amazon Prime and it popped up as a suggestion so I was like “… sure, what the hell!”.

before-i-go-to-sleep-dvd-cover-29

The main actors in the movie are Nicole Kidman as Christine, Colin Firth as “Ben”/Mike and Mark Strong as Dr. Nasch. While I wouldn’t personally have cast any of these people in the roles, they were all fantastic and Colin Firth as a bad guy was especially shocking!

The movie is very true to the book and since I loved the book, I absolutely adored the movie. I’m sure the plot isn’t for everyone but the basic jist is a lady called Christine suffers from a severe form of amnesia, after a horrific incident several years before. Each morning she wakes up believing she is in her 20’s, when actually she is in her 40’s and has forgotten everything that has happened in between. Every morning is a clean slate and she has to start learning about herself all over again, along with her husband Ben and with the help of Dr. Nasch. Bit by bit she manages to remember parts of her past, and while for the most part she still continues to forget it each day, with the help of a video diary (just a regular diary in the book), learning each day becomes a quicker process. The book/movie is definitely a thriller, so expect a dark twist. The whole movie is done quite slow and creepy though so I think if you haven’t read the book you wouldn’t always be entirely sure where it was going.

This book/movie adaptation has now shot in as one of my all time favourites, along with Hunger Games, The Fault in Our Stars and Divergent. I will still continue to recommend the book to everyone and now also the movie too!